noted.do
The Tech Guy

Cookies Aren't the Villain. Third Parties Are

Every site greets you with a cookie banner now, which has given cookies a pretty bad name. That's a little unfair. Cookies are the reason you stay logged in when you go from one page to the next. Without them, every click would forget who you are. The problem isn't cookies as a technology. It's who gets to set them and what they do with them.

Mechanically, a cookie is tiny. When your browser loads a page, the server can include a header that says "store this": a name, a value, and some rules about when it expires and which site it belongs to. From then on, every time your browser makes a request to that site, it sends the cookie back. That's how a shop remembers your cart, how your email knows you already signed in, and how a site remembers you picked dark mode. These are first-party cookies, set by the site you're actually on, and most of them are completely boring.

Things get interesting when a page pulls in content from somewhere else. A news article might load an ad from an ad network, a "like" button from a social media company, and an analytics script from a third company. Each of those is a request to a different domain, and each of those domains can set and read its own cookie in your browser. Those are third-party cookies.

Now picture the same ad network embedded on thousands of sites. Every time you hit one of them, your browser sends that network its cookie, along with which page you're on. The network doesn't need your name. It has a unique ID and a growing list of everything that ID has read, shopped for and searched. Stitch that together and you've got a profile detailed enough to guess your income, health worries and politics. That's the tracking people mean when they complain about cookies.

Browsers have been pushing back on this. Safari and Firefox block most third-party cookies by default, and Brave goes further. Chrome has gone back and forth on its own plans over the years, so I won't try to describe exactly where it stands, but the general direction across the industry has been toward limiting cross-site cookies.

Here's the catch, though. Trackers adapted. Blocking third-party cookies helped, but it didn't end tracking, because there are other ways to recognize you:

Fingerprinting looks at the specific combination of your browser, screen size, installed fonts, graphics card, time zone and a pile of other details. Individually they're common. Together they can be close to unique, and there's nothing stored on your machine to delete.

Link decoration sticks an ID right in the URL. If you've ever seen ?fbclid= or ?gclid= on the end of a link, that's what it is. The ID rides along to the next site no matter what your cookie settings are.

Tracking pixels are invisible one-pixel images in pages and emails. Loading the image tells the sender you opened it, when, and roughly where.

And then there's the simplest one: logging in. If you're signed in to a big platform, it doesn't need third-party tricks to know who you are on its own properties, and its embeds elsewhere can often connect the dots.

So what do I actually do about it? A few things that are low effort and make a real difference:

Use a browser with tracking protection turned on, and leave it on. Firefox, Safari and Brave all do a lot by default.

Add a content blocker. uBlock Origin is the one I'd point most people to. It blocks the tracking scripts from loading in the first place, which handles a lot of the fingerprinting and pixel stuff too.

Don't stay logged in to big social platforms in the same browser you use for everything else. Firefox's container tabs make this easy, or just use a separate browser profile for them.

When a cookie banner offers "Reject all," click it. The law in some regions requires that option to be as easy as "Accept," and it does actually stop a lot of the third-party scripts on compliant sites.

Turn off remote image loading in your email app if it supports it, or use one that blocks tracking pixels for you.

None of this makes you invisible, and I don't think that's a realistic goal for normal browsing. The goal is to stop being the easiest profile on the internet to build. That bar is lower than people think.

Comments

Be kind. See the rules.